Return to CreateDebate.comwdc1101 • Join this debate community

1101


Debate Info

4
4
Yes No. It's not free speech.
Debate Score:8
Arguments:8
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (4)
 
 No. It's not free speech. (4)

Debate Creator

ehawkins(408) pic



Would Amending the Constitution to Prohibit the Burning of the US Flag Limit Free Speech?

Is it a first amendment issue or is it akin to physical assault?

Yes

Side Score: 4
VS.

No. It's not free speech.

Side Score: 4

Everyone has the freedom to say what they think. Telling someone that they aren't allowed to do something and say what they think is against the constitution itself. Many people probably don't like the U.S. and they have the right to say and show that.

Side: Yes
ehawkins(408) Disputed
1 point

Many people don't like each other. Should we just allow violence?

Side: No. It's not free speech.
1 point

As Americans we have the freedom of speech which means if we have bad things to express about our country we are able to. Burning the flag means nothing more than expressing our dislike for the way things are in the country. It's not hurting others.

Side: Yes
1 point

Free speech is speaking one's mind without getting arrested for saying it. Free speech, however, does not allow someone to do whatever they want. For example, they can speak out about a politician's views. They can not destroy property or assault someone though. The same goes for the flag. You can speak against it, but you shouldn't destroy it. Especially if it is someone else's property.

Side: No. It's not free speech.
ehawkins(408) Disputed
1 point

Destroying someone else's property is illegal. Expressing your own opinion should never be illegal. If we start stopping our rights to say what we think, we may as well just stop voting.

Side: Yes
1 point

The first amendment gives all citizens the right to free speech, but this is being used on topics that have nothing to do with free speech. One being burning the American flag. The American flag symbolizes freedom and democracy which is why people have made the argument that burning the flag is speech, but that is not the case. The freedom of speech was given so that people could voice their opinions without being tried and convicted for treason, which has nothing to do with the American flag. This because the flag is a symbol of the entire nation, not just certain topics, and should be treated and therefore protected as such.

Side: No. It's not free speech.
ehawkins(408) Disputed
1 point

It's a piece of fabric. You cannot tell people how to view a piece of cloth. Symbolically it can represent that to certain people, but for many people the American flag is a symbol of oppression. SO, if it is that for many people, shouldn't more people be burning it?

Side: Yes
18mevans(6) Disputed
1 point

By that logic, the flag of the Islamic State is offensive to most people, but if someone were to burn it, it woukdn't be categorized as freedom of speech, it would be categorized as a hate crime. So why should burning the American flag be ny different.

Side: No. It's not free speech.